As a hospital executive or physician group leader, you’re (unfortunately) very familiar with insurance underpayments. They’re an ever-aching thorn in your side and a direct attack on your establishment’s financial stability.
Aside from underpayments draining your resources, they also force you to make difficult decisions about staffing, investments, and patient care. But you don’t have to let underpayments back you into a corner. When you understand the true cost of these underpayments, you take the first step toward claiming the out-of-network reimbursement your facility deserves.
(DC Studio/Freepik)
The Financial Weight of Underpayments
When insurers consistently pay less than the fair value of your services, the cumulative impact is staggering. A single underpaid claim may not seem catastrophic, but across hundreds or thousands of cases, the losses quickly add up to millions.
If you’re managing an extensive hospital system, even a 10–15% underpayment on a high volume of out-of-network claims can create a large gap in your budget. For physician groups in specialties like anesthesiology, radiology, or emergency medicine, underpayments hit even harder. Your services are frequently billed in out-of-network contexts, making disputes common and underpayments the norm.
These underpayments mean you’re losing money and the ability to plan with confidence. Financial loss and uncertainty permeate every corner of your facility—not exactly the environment you want for your staff or patients.
The Operational Strain on Your Organization
Insurance underpayments even affect your day-to-day operations. You may find yourself forced to delay upgrading medical equipment, reduce staff hours, or cut back on training programs, all in the name of balancing the budget.
Another hidden cost is the strain on your billing and administrative teams. Every underpayment requires extensive paperwork and follow-ups, pulling staff away from other priorities. For executives, this leads to inefficiency and burnout among team members who are constantly fighting uphill battles against insurers.
When your staff feels overwhelmed, morale suffers. Instead of focusing on improving patient outcomes or building stronger provider-insurer relationships, your teams are stuck in endless cycles of disputes and denials.
The Impact on Patient Care
Perhaps the most damaging consequence of insurance underpayments is their indirect effect on patient care. When you lack resources due to underpayment, you might have to make difficult choices about staffing levels, program expansion, or facility improvements.
These decisions inevitably affect your ability to deliver the highest quality of care. Patient waiting rooms fill up because you can’t afford a full staff. You have to send many patients to a better-equipped facility because you can’t invest in the newest diagnostic equipment. Patients rarely see the financial negotiations behind the scenes, but they absolutely feel the negative impact.
When you allow insurers to dictate reimbursement without challenge, you risk creating a vicious cycle: underpayments compromise your ability to serve patients, so they go elsewhere and you lose out on even more revenue.
Why Providers Accept Underpayments
So why do so many hospitals and physician groups accept these losses? The answer lies in the barriers that prevent providers from pushing back.
- Time pressure: The No Surprises Act (NSA) and state laws have strict deadlines that are difficult to meet without a dedicated team.
- Upfront costs: Filing fees for arbitration discourage many providers, especially when the claim amount doesn’t seem worth the risk.
- Complexity: Navigating NSA arbitration rules or state-specific systems requires expertise that most billing teams don’t have.
Because of these hurdles, many organizations choose to accept low reimbursements rather than fight for what they’re owed. Insurers count on this inaction to save money, and it works.
The Long-Term Consequences of Doing Nothing
When you repeatedly accept underpayments, the consequences extend well beyond today’s balance sheet. Over time, consistent revenue losses erode your financial resilience. You’re less able to invest in staff development, less capable of expanding services, and more vulnerable to shifts in payer policies.
The healthcare environment is already challenging: rising labor costs and increasingly tight regulations make it a harsh industry. Allowing insurers to dictate your revenue only intensifies these pressures. When you don’t address underpayments, you essentially hand over control of your financial future to big insurance corporations.
How Arbitration Can Turn the Tide
The good news is that you don’t have to accept underpayments as inevitable. Arbitration, especially under the NSA, provides a structured way to challenge insurers and recover what you’re owed.
Arbitration consistently favors providers when it’s used correctly. Arbitrators look at fair market data, historical reimbursement rates, and the complexity of services, not just the insurer’s lowball offer. With well-prepared cases, providers often recover five to ten times more than the initial payment.
For your organization, this can mean millions of dollars in recovered revenue each year. More importantly, it shifts the balance of power, proving that insurers can’t count on your inaction.
Reducing Risk While Maximizing Recovery
You may hesitate to pursue arbitration because of the costs and resources involved. But there are contingency-based solutions that eliminate this risk. Investing in arbitration representation for out-of-network providers with no upfront cost connects you with experts who advance filing fees and handle the process from start to finish. This way, you can pursue arbitration without exposing your organization to upfront costs.
This approach not only improves your chances of success but also frees your staff to focus on other priorities. Instead of fighting insurers alone, you have a partner who treats your revenue as if it were their own.
Your Role as a Healthcare Executive
As a healthcare executive, you play a critical role in ensuring your organization doesn’t leave money on the table. Accepting underpayments may seem easier in the short term, but it creates long-term vulnerabilities. By championing arbitration and recovery strategies, you demonstrate leadership in financial stewardship.
Your willingness to fight underpayments signals to staff, patients, and insurers alike that your organization is resilient. It allows you to redirect recovered revenue into the programs and services that matter most, from hiring more nurses to upgrading your technology.
The Cost of Inaction Is Too High
The true cost of insurance underpayments goes far beyond missed revenue. It disrupts your operations, strains your staff, weakens patient care, and jeopardizes your financial future. But you don’t have to accept it.
By embracing arbitration and recovery strategies, you can transform underpayments into opportunities for growth and stability. The money is there; insurers just hope you won’t pursue it. When you decide to act, you reclaim revenue and control over your organization’s future.