The Recovery Platform That Wins and Collects
A Legacy of Advocacy for Medical Providers
Callagy Law, founded in 1999 by Sean Callagy, was established to help medical providers combat underpayment and insurance carrier delays. As the firm grew, it expanded its focus and now, through its affiliate Callagy Recovery Corp., is a nationwide arbitration platform that has scaled from 5 to over 100 employees, recovering $1.6 Billion+ for clients at a $100M monthly run rate.
Today, Callagy Recovery Corp. specializes in state and federal surprise medical bill arbitrations, empowering medical providers to fully leverage the No Surprises Act (NSA) and state no surprise laws for fair, fast, and complete reimbursement.
Who We Are
We exist to eliminate every barrier between providers and the revenue they’ve already earned. The No Surprises Act created a binding federal arbitration remedy when payers underpay, but 90% of eligible claims go unfiled, and even winners routinely fail to collect.
Callagy closes both gaps: legal-grade filings that win at 90%+, and law-firm enforcement that collects at 93%. For a health system, that’s $1M–$8M+ in net annual EBITDA per hospital, at zero out-of-pocket cost.
What We Do
We guide medical practices through the federal NSA arbitration process—a process riddled with strict deadlines, high fees, and confusing compliance requirements.
Instead of accepting pennies on the dollar from carriers, we file arbitration cases directly, handle the complexities, and maximize your payment.
Our Impact
$1.6 Billion+*
Recovered
90%+ win rate on arbitration determinations
93% Post-award collection rate (vs. 40–50% industry average)
How We Help Providers
- Navigate all NSA deadlines with precision — 30-day, 10-day, and 4-day windows
- Advance all filing fees ($1,000+/case) — $0 upfront, 20% contingent, zero capital at risk
- Deploy deep forum intelligence across 13 federal venues with weekly arbitrator contact
- File attorney-reviewed, defensible submissions every time with a 90%+ win rate
- Enforce and collect awards at 93% vs. a 40–50% industry average where most wins are never collected
- Educate your billing and admin teams on the revenue opportunities you’re currently missing
Meet the Team
Sean Callagy, Esq.
President & Chief Executive Officer
Thomas LaGreca, Esq.
Chief Growth Officer & General Counsel
Mark Winters, MHA
Chief Operating Officer