Arbitration Support For Medical Providers
A Legacy of Advocacy for Medical Providers
Callagy Law, founded in 1999 by Sean Callagy, was established to help medical providers combat underpayment and insurance carrier delays. As the firm grew, it expanded its focus and now, through its affiliate Callagy Recovery Corp., is a nationwide arbitration powerhouse.
Today, Callagy Recovery Corp. specializes in state and federal surprise medical bill arbitrations, empowering medical providers to fully leverage the No Surprises Act (NSA) and state no surprise laws for fair, fast, and complete reimbursement.
Who We Are
Our mission is simple: to advocate for healthcare providers and secure proper reimbursements from insurance companies. We believe that providers should focus on delivering exceptional patient care without the burden of pursuing denied or underpaid claims.
By partnering with us, you can trust that our team of experts is working tirelessly to ensure you are compensated accurately and fairly.
What We Do
We guide medical practices through the federal NSA arbitration process—a process riddled with strict deadlines, high fees, and confusing compliance requirements.
Instead of accepting pennies on the dollar from carriers, we file arbitration cases directly, handle the complexities, and maximize your payment.
Our Impact
$1,305,935,101*
Total Awarded To Our Clients
90%+ win rate on arbitration determinations
Average 980% reimbursement boost
per claim
How We Help Providers
- Navigate all NSA deadlines with precision (30-day, 10-day, and 4-day windows)
- Front the entire cost of arbitration filing—no financial risk
to you - Strategically select arbitration forums to improve your odds
- Submit compliant, detailed, forum-ready cases
- Educate your billing and admin teams on the opportunities you’re missing
Meet the Team
Sean Callagy, Esq.
President & CEO
Thomas LaGreca, Esq.
Chief Growth Officer
Mark Winters, MHA
Chief Operating Officer